Penns Grove, New Jersey
Every pie is shaped by hand, baked with intention, and served with the kind of warmth that turns first-time visitors into neighbors who never leave.
Est.
Penns Grove
Our Story
Andy's Pizza isn't a franchise. It isn't a chain. It's a corner of Penns Grove where the dough is stretched by hand every morning, the sauce simmers for hours, and the oven never stops running.
Located on South Virginia Avenue, we've been serving our community with the same standards Andy set from day one: real ingredients, honest portions, and the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like you're eating at someone's kitchen table — because you are.
100%
Hand-Stretched Dough
Fresh
Local Ingredients
Real
Wood-Fired Flavor
What We Do Best
Every pie on our menu is crafted the same way — with care, respect for the ingredients, and zero shortcuts.
Our namesake pie — a generous layer of house-made tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a hint of oregano on our signature hand-tossed crust. Simple, bold, unforgettable.
Cup-and-char pepperoni that crisps at the edges, blanketed over melted mozzarella and our slow-simmered sauce. It's the pie that keeps people coming back.
Fresh bell peppers, mushrooms, black olives, red onions, and spinach piled high on a bed of ricotta and mozzarella. Fresh from the garden, straight to your pie.
From game nights to office lunches, we cater with the same quality you'd expect at the table. Call us to plan your event — we'll handle the pies.
Pull up a chair in our warm dining room, grab your pie to go, or let us bring it to your door. however you get it, it arrives hot and made right.
From the Oven
What Our Neighbors Say
"The best pizza in the area, hands down. The crust is always perfect — crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. My family comes here every Friday night and it's become our tradition."
Local Regular
Penns Grove
"We ordered catering for our office party and every single person asked where we got the pizza. The Andy Special is out of this world. We're ordering again next month for sure."
Office Event
Catering Order
"You can tell they actually care about what they're making. The vegetables on the veggie pie are fresh, the crust has that perfect char. This is what real pizza should taste like."
Pizza Enthusiast
Visit 2025
Find Us
Address
213 S Virginia Ave
Penns Grove, NJ 08069
Phone
(856) 299-1600Hours
Monday – Thursday: 11am – 9pm
Friday – Saturday: 11am – 10pm
Sunday: 12pm – 9pm
Have a question, want to place a catering order, or just want to say hello? We'd love to hear from you.
Message Sent!
We'll get back to you within 24 hours.
